Sensors - August 2003 - Tunable Lasers for Multichannel Fiber-Optic Sensors

Tunable lasers, highly manufacturable and cost-effective, are opening new opportunities for multichannel fiber Bragg grating sensors using single-fiber and single-laser technology in multiple-point interrogation systems.

Fiber-optic sensors are becoming more and more popular for measuring strain, temperature, pressure, angular rotation speed, acceleration, and many other parameters. These devices are immune to EMI and can work in harsh chemical and radioactive environments. Commercial development is flourishing due to the ad-vancement of fiber and optoelectronic components developed for the fiber-optic telecommunications market.

Operating Principle
One new type of fiber sensor is the fiber Bragg grating (FBG) sensor [1,2]. Briefly put, an FBG is a portion of optical fiber whose refractive index has periodical changes along its length. It works as a partially reflecting mirror with a narrow (<0.2 nm) spectral peak. What is important is that the reflectivity peak’s central wavelength is determined by the grating period (see Figure 1A). Under longitudinal strain, both the period and the peak reflectivity wavelength change. Under tension, the peak wavelength shifts toward longer wavelengths; under compression, it shifts toward shorter wavelengths (see Figure 1B).

Figure 1. The fiber Bragg grating (FBG) reflects light in a narrow spectral range with a central wavelength defined by a period of grating, or spacing (A). Under tensile strain conditions, the central wavelength shifts toward a longer wavelength and under compression it shifts toward a shorter one (B).

This wavelength shift depends linearly on strain with a coefficient of ~1.2 pm/µ

. Similarly, the wavelength changes with temperature at a rate of 1.3 pm/°C.

To detect such changes in the peak wavelength, we must either measure the light intensity in a very narrow spectral window, or have a light source with a stable wavelength and narrow linewidth. In the former case, the input signal can be a broad-spectrum light source, such as superluminescent LEDs, with a narrow optical filter at the detector side whose wavelength is close to the center of an unstrained FBG’s reflectivity peak. In the latter case, the input source can be lasers with stabilized wavelengths, such as temperature-stabilized semiconductor distributed feedback (DFB) lasers or fiber lasers. FBG sensors can measure strain or temperature at the grating’s location. For measurements at multiple points (e.g., strain in buildings, bridges, or airplane wings), multiple fibers with FBG sensors must be installed.

FBGs can easily be made for different central wavelengths, so it is very attractive to use gratings designed for different wavelengths in a single fiber (see Figure 2).

Figure 2. In the multichannel interrogation system, the FBGs of different central wavelengths are used at different points of the fiber. Each FBG detects strain at its own fiber location.

For instance, a multiple-channel interrogation system can be designed to measure strain or temperature at multiple locations using one fiber [3]. As in the single-channel systems, there are two ways of detecting the signal. In the first, a broad-spectrum source is the input signal, and either multiple narrow-band filters or a tunable filter is used for the detector. The second approach requires either multiple lasers with wavelengths adjusted to individual gratings, or tunable laser sources. Tunable filters and laser sources are attractive because they decrease the overall system cost. Their fast, repeatable wavelength sweep allows real-time monitoring of rapid changes in stress, extremely important for industries such as aircraft or shipping.

Tunable Sources and Filters for Fiber Interrogators
The important parameters of light sources for FBG interrogators are optical power, tuning range, tuning speed, and continuous tuning capabilities. For commercialization, manufacturability is also a key consideration. Several approaches to tunable sources and filters have been developed and commercialized (see Table 1).

Table 1
Comparison of Various Tunable Technologies for FBG Interrogation Systems
Laser Type	Optical Power	Tuning Range (nm)	Tuning Type	Tuning Speed	Manufac- turability
Broadband source with tunable filter	0.02 per 1 A	40	Continuous	100 ms	Low (hybrid integration)
Temperature-tuned DFB laser	10	4	Continuous	~1 s	High
Multisection DBR laser	1	40	Digital (ITU grid)	10 ns	Low
External cavity laser	1-10	40	Continuous	100 ms	Low (hybrid integration)
Optically pumped VCSEL	1-10	40	Continuous	100 µs	Low (hybrid integration)
MEMS-tunable VCSEL	0.2-0.5	20	Continuous	100 µs	High

First, let’s consider a broad-spectrum light source with a tunable filter at the detector side. Tunable filters, based on a Fabry-Pérot etalon with moving mirrors, provide broad (up to 40 nm) continuous tuning at a speed on the order of 0.1 s. To achieve high measurement resolution, the tunable filter bandwidth has to be narrow, using only a small fraction of optical power (0.02 mW/0.1 nm of the band). Tunable filters typically require hybrid integration, making for low manufacturability.

Among the tunable laser sources we will examine are DFB lasers, multisection distributed Bragg reflector (DBR) lasers, external cavity lasers, optically pumped vertical cavity surface emitting lasers (VCSELs), and monolithic VCSELs with MEMS structures for tuning (see Figure 3).

Figure 3. Multisection distributed Bragg reflector (DBR) lasers, external cavity lasers, optically pumped VCSELs, or monolithic MEMS VCSELs can be used as tunable light sources for multichannel FBG systems.

Temperature-Tuned DFB Lasers. These lasers are readily available commercial devices (Mitsubishi, Agere). Their optical power can easily be as high as 10 mW and their lasing wavelength changes continuously with temperature at a rate of ~0.1 nm/°C. So to tune over only 4 nm, the operating temperature should be changed by 40°C, which is close to the practical limit of the temperature

Key to Initials

DBR. Distributed Bragg reflector.

DFB. Distributed feedback.

DWDM. Dense-wavelength-division multiplexed.

FBG. Fiber Bragg grating.

SEM. Scanning electron microscope.

VCSEL. Vertical cavity surface emitting laser.

range. Despite their high power, simplicity, and manufacturability, their slow tunability as determined by their thermal time constant (~1 s) and their narrow tunable range limit their applications.

Multisection DBR Lasers. These fiber pigtailed lasers (Agility) are 4–5 contact devices that provide broad (up to 40 nm) tuning with a power of ~1 mW. Rather than being continuously tunable, they are switchable devices. They were developed for dense-wavelength-division multipleýed (DWDM) telecommunications systems, and tuned from one to another ITU (International Telecommunication Union) grid point separated by 50 or 100 GHz. Tuning can be as fast as a dozen nanoseconds, as determined by the electronic properties of the p–n junction. Very complicated processing technology makes their manufacturing difficult and the requisite elaborate controls complicate their electronics.

External Cavity Lasers. In these lasers, commercially available from Iolon and NewFocus, the output of the semiconductor laser chip is optically coupled to an external diffractive grating and tuned by rotating an external mirror. They have high power (1–10 mW) and continuous tuning over a >40 nm range, but have a fairly slow tuning speed (~0.1 s). Because of their complex optical scheme and hybrid packaging, they are quite complicated to manufacture.

Optically Pumped VCSELs. These complex optical systems, incorporating a pump laser and a vertical cavity laser with a tuning structure, require complicated hybrid packaging. Despite their 1–10 mW of power and continuous tuning over 40 nm, Nortel, their manufacturer, has discontinued them.

Resources

Temperature-Tunable DFB Lasers
Mitsubishi
Agere

Multisectional Tunable DFB Lasers
Agility

External Cavity Lasers
Iolon
NewFocus

Optically Pumped VCSELs
Nortel

MEMS-Based Monolithic VCSELs
Bandwidth9, Inc.

Monolithic VCSELs. MEMS-based continuously tunable electrically pumped VCSELs from Bandwidth9, Inc., have moderate power (0.2–0.5 mW) and broad tuning over a 20 nm range. They are characterized by fast tuning (~100 µs) and high manufacturability. Let’s now examine these devices in more detail.

Tunable MEMS VCSELs
VCSELs, emitting in the 1.55 µm wavelength region, are very appealing laser sources for low-cost sensor systems because of their capacity to be tested at the wafer level. They also feature intrinsic single-longitudinal mode, low threshold currents, and low power consumption [4]. For MEMS-based tunable VCSELs, wavelength tuning is continuous and simply controlled by a voltage applied to the MEMS structure [5]. In contrast to other tunable lasers such as multisection DBR lasers, emission wavelength control over time implies only a closed loop on the voltage to compensate for any aging effects. This simplicity of tuning lends itself to very good operability in a real sensor configuration.

Figure 4. In the MEMS tunable VCSEL, an applied tuning voltage controls an air gap between the cantilever tuning arm and the wafer base, which, in turn, defines the lasing wavelength.

Figure 5. The width of the air gap between the tuning arm and the wafer base is ~2 mm, as shown in this SEM micrograph of a MEMS structure.

The devices are grown in a single sequence by molecular beam epitaxy. The photolithographically defined cantilever is formed by etching. Wafer-scale processing and testing make MEMS VCSELs very manufacturable. An air gap between the cantilever tuning arm and the wafer base defines the laser’s optical cavity length which, in turn, defines the lasing wavelength. Continuous wavelength tuning is provided by the electrostatic attraction of the cantilever arm to the wafer base when the tuning voltage is applied to the arm. Due to a narrow air gap (~2 µm), tunable VCSELs are intrinsically single longitudinal-mode devices. Figure 5 is an SEM micrograph of a

Figure 6. Better than 20 nm wavelength tuning is achieved at the tuning voltages 0–44 V.

cantilever structure. The simple voltage tuning mechanism allows the development of inexpensive simple control circuitry.

The most important characteristic of tunable VCSELs is the laser wavelength’s dependence on the applied tuning voltage. Better than 20 nm tuning is achieved at 0–44 V (see Figure 6). The laser operates at a single frequency, with a side-mode suppression ratio >45 dB across the entire tuning range (see Figure 7) and at temperatures up to 75°C (see Figure 8), while maintaining a low threshold current. The laser linewidth is <200 MHz, or 1.5 pm.

Figure 7. The tunable MEMS VCSEL operates at a single frequency with a high side mode suppression ratio (>45 dB) across the entire tuning range.

Figure 8. The laser operates at up to 75ºC at low threshold currents.

The cantilever tuning arm is fabricated of a single-crystal semiconductor material and is very robust. At all tuning positions, its angular deflection is <0.1°, and has been experimentally demonstrated capable of surviving billions of tuning cycles. The arm’s mechanical properties can be described through the spectral transfer function of wavelength vs. tuning voltage. Its mechanical resonant frequency is measured by turning the VCSEL on and monitoring the output wavelength change through a filter while sweeping a small modulated signal across the tuning voltage bias. The small signal transfer function of two typical MEMS VCSELs is shown in Figure 9.

Figure 9. The resonant frequencies of the tuning arms are ~80 kHz, as can be seen from the small signal response frequency characteristics of the tuning arms of two VCSELs.

The arm’s resonant frequency of ~80 kHz and damping time of <1 ms allow it to be easily controlled up to frequencies of 10–20 kHz. These features translate into a tuning speed of 400,000 nm/s.

Summary
Tunable MEMS VCSELs emitting in the 1.55 µm region have several advantages over competing technologies, among them a simple growth process and wafer-scale fabrication, testing, and screening. They are single mode, mode-hop free in operation. The cantilever and thin air gap make tuning simple, with only a single voltage applied to the tuning arm. The arm’s mechanical structure allows tuning up to 400,000 nm/s across the entire tuning range. The arm is robust, with a failure rate better than 150 FITs (one failure per 1 billion device hours of operation). Finally these VCSELs are a highly manufacturable, reliable, and cost-effective solution for multichannel FBG interrogating systems.

References
1. Kersley, A.D., et al., “Fiber Grating Sensors,” J. of Lightwave Technology, Vol. 15, No. 8, pp. 1442–1463, 1997.

2. Fuhr, Peter L., “Measuring with Light,” Sensors, Vol. 17, No. 5, May 2000.

3. Lee, B., and Y. Jeong, “Interrogation Techniques for Fiber Grating Sensors and the Theory of Fiber Gratings,” Fiber Optic Sensors, Ch. 7, F.T.S. Yu and S. Yin, eds., pp. 295–381, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, 2002.

4. Yuen, W., et al., “High-performance 1.6 mm single-epitaxy-top-emitting-VCSEL,” Elec. Lett., Vol. 36, pp. 1–2, 2000.

5. Chang-Hasnain, C., “Tunable VC- SELS,” IEEE J. of Select. Top. Quant. Elec., Vol. 6, No. 6, pp. 978–987, Nov./Dec. 2000.

These comments relate to statements made regarding multi-section DBR lasers and their inherent performance capabilities in the article entitled "Tunable Lasers for Multichannel Fiber-Optic Sensors" Quoting from the article:

“Multisection DBR Lasers. These fiber pigtailed lasers (Agility) are 4–5 contact devices that provide broad (up to 40 nm) tuning with a power of ~1 mW. “

Comment: These devices have output power of 10mW with an additional Semiconductor Optical Amplifier Section that can boost power to 20mW when required.

“Rather than being continuously tunable, they are switchable devices.”

Comment: These devices are quasi-continuously tunable, i.e. they can reach every wavelength possible across the C and L-bands by being tuned in approximately 200 continuous segments.

“They were developed for dense-wavelength-division multipleýed (DWDM) telecommunications systems, and tuned from one to another ITU (International Telecommunication Union) grid point separated by 50 or 100 GHz.”

Comment: These lasers can tune to any wavelength on any grid across the C or L band.

“Very complicated processing technology makes their manufacturing difficult”

Comment: In fact, it uses similar manufacturing steps to the DFB laser which is widespread use. It has the same large packaging cost as all monolithic laser chips: e.g. coupling the chip to the fibre and sub-micron alignments. The growth of the chip itself is well understood process and has similar yields to the DFB.

“ and the requisite elaborate controls complicate their electronics.”

Comment: The electronics consists of stored operating points, current sources and temperature controller. Calibration is indeed complicated but the advantage of electronic tuning is that there is no moving part that can degrade, and temperature and degradation changes within the laser can be compensated for quickly and efficiently using electronic control.

Comment: The following table clearly shows why this technology is the most suited for real field deployable industrial sensor applications: it can achieve economies of scale and hence low cost as it is deployed widely in telecoms going forward, it can tune to any wavelength, it is electronically controlled making integration possible, it can work over a wide temperature range, it has long term active stability control and finally it can tune so fast that it makes a wide variety of real time, high frequency sensing applications possible that were not possible before, such as measurement of 10kHz acoustic signals on a passive optical filter.

Table

Comparison of Various Tunable Technologies for
FBG Interrogation Systems

Laser
Type Optical
Power Tuning
Range (nm) Tuning
Type Tuning
Speed Manufac-
turability

Broadband source with tunable filter 0.02 per 1 A 40 Continuous 100 ms Low (hybrid integration)

Temperature-tuned DFB laser 10 4 Continuous ~1 s High

Multisection DBR laser 10 40 Quasi-continuous 10 ns High

External cavity laser 1-10 40 Continuous 100 ms Low (hybrid integration)

Optically pumped VCSEL 1-10 40 Continuous 100 µs Low (hybrid integration)

MEMS-tunable VCSEL 0.2-0.5 20 Continuous 100 µs High

Comment: Intune Technologies uses these laser types in shipped product today, with a variety of tuning characteristics such as:

Intune AltoNet1200: 200 nano-second switching and active locking from any channel to any channel on the ITU grid
Intune AltoWave5500: Full spectral sweep across C band for optical sensor interrogation with 0.1pm repeatability over 0-50C temperature range

These types of products have significant real advantages over lasers based on mechanical parts due to their robustness, integration potential, speed, long-term active reliability control and low cost.

John Dunne
CEO
Intune Technologies